Landfill Site Selection by Integrating Fuzzy Logic, Analytical Hierarchy Process and Weighted Linear Combination Method Based on Multi Criteria Decision Analysis

Abstract

Rapid population growth integrated with poor governance and urban planning is of highly challenging resulting key for the siting of unsuitable landfill sites, particularly in developing counties. Therefore, the aim of this study was to identify the appropriate solid waste landfill sites in the capital of the country as a case study, by the integration of Geographical Information System (GIS) with weighted linear combination (WLC) method, analytical hierarchy process (AHP) and fuzzy logic based on multi criteria decision making (MCDM). We chose thirteen (13) criteria (9 factors and 4 constraints) and grouped them in two main categories (socio-economic and environmental) to obtain the objectives. The AHP was employed to evaluate the relative importance of the factors followed by standardization of criteria factors based on fuzzy set theory. Subsequently, all criteria factors were combined based on AHP and fuzzy logic-WLC method in order to obtain land suitability map. Finally, the sites were identified by the intersection of two combined suitability index layers. The obtained results depicted that the integration fuzzy logic, AHP and WLC technique with GIS can produce satisfactory results for the suitable locations of solid waste landfill sites over complex topographic regions. Overall, the land suitability obtained based on fuzzy-WLC is more refined and smooth because of its better segregation and its potential to consider full tradeoff between factors and average risk. The AHP identified (47 km2) as high suitable while fuzzy-WLC generated 36 km2 as suitable area. Finally, the intersection of both suitability index map shows numerous suitable landfill sites available in Islamabad city, however, the surface areas of the sites is small at individual level (less than 15 hectare).