Abstract:
Prototyping is an essential part of the product design and development process that
assists in the implementation of a conceptualized design. 3D-printing has been widely
utilized as a prototype method since the 2000s when it became prominent as an additive
manufacturing process. The inherent rapid prototyping ability offered by 3D-printing
coupled with the need to be able to develop customized daily use applications remains to
be the highlight of the present study. This study consists of the development of a hair
clipper comb model, impact test analysis, and fabrication of the product using
commercially available materials. 3D model of comb for Philips hair clipper was
developed using ONSHPAE software, followed by a design study with various materials
to understand the impact resistance of the product. The design study was performed via
finite element (FE) explicit dynamic mode, where two hair clipper comb designs, one
with a solid body and the other with a shell were subjected to drop test simulation in two
orientations: leg and head drop. Two readily available 3D-printable plastic materials,
Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene (ABS) and Polylactic acid (PLA) were selected for the
FE simulation while the comb was subjected to free fall from a height of 5 ft (1.67 m).
Simulations reveal that the maximum von Mises stress for solid PLA model in head and
leg drop configurations are 56.4 MPa and 60.4 MPa respectively, while for the hollow
design (shell model), the values are seen to be 40.3 MPa, 30.9 MPa respectively.
Similarly, for solid ABS the stress values are found to be 42.8 MPa (head drop
configuration) and 34.3 MPa (leg drop configuration) whereas in the hollow model
(shell) the values recorded are 30.6 MPa and 26.9 MPa, respectively. To validate the
results, the 4 models were fabricated using 3D Printing and were manually dropped from
the same height. In line with the simulated results, models prepared from PLA material
failed upon the impact while ABS samples having a comparatively better impact
resistance sustained the impact without failure. Moreover, fracture surface morphology
of the failed PLA component and the surface of ABS in a printed condition were
analyzed using Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM). The microscopic examination
was performed to analyze the quality of 3D-printed clipper comb and correlate the
9
defects with failure mechanism. The shell model made up of ABS material turns out to
be the most suitable choice out of the various designs considered.